Ta-Nehisi Coates' The Message is not merely a book; it's a potent and unflinching examination of history, power, and the narratives that shape our understanding of the world. This collection of essays, drawn from his work at The Atlantic, pierces through the comfortable illusions we often cling to, demanding a confrontation with uncomfortable truths.
Coates begins by grounding us in his own formative experiences, recounting the impact of a seemingly random tragedy on a celebrated athlete told in Sports Illustrated. This early encounter with the inherent unfairness of life becomes a recurring motif, a lens through which he views the larger injustices he dissects.
In On Pharaohs, Coates delves into the insidious construction of racial hierarchies. He exposes the hypocrisy of figures like Teddy Roosevelt, who championed a "civilizing" mission while conveniently ignoring the rich history and achievements of African civilizations. The concept of ‘Niggerology,’ the creation of a racial hierarchy to justify colonial ambitions, is laid bare. Furthermore, Coates offers a startling observation about the internal hierarchies within Black communities, where perceived prestige and proximity to whiteness can lead to a "mixed-race" categorization even within Black parentage. This nuanced point highlights the pervasive influence of white societal valuations.
Bearing the Flaming Cross shifts focus to the limitations of traditional education. Coates reflects on his own undiagnosed ADHD and critiques a system that prioritizes rote memorization over genuine understanding and application of knowledge. He champions the spirit of the Harlem Renaissance and the educational philosophy of Paulo Freire, both emphasizing the power of education as a tool for liberation and social change. The rise of right-wing outrage against discussions of race and history, particularly in the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement, is presented as a deliberate attempt to suppress challenging narratives and maintain a sanitized version of the past. Coates powerfully argues that without honest confrontation with our history, progress remains elusive.
The longest and perhaps most impactful section, The Gigantic Dream, embarks on a global exploration of historical denial and the narratives that underpin power structures. Coates' visit to the Holocaust Museum prompts a stark comparison with the often-erased history of the genocide of First Nations people in America, echoing the hypocrisy seen in To Kill A Mockingbird.
His analysis of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is particularly compelling and courageous. He draws parallels between the treatment of Palestinians and the Jim Crow South, highlighting the two-tiered system that privileges Jewish Israelis while denying basic rights and freedoms to Palestinians. Through conversations with former IDF soldiers, Coates exposes the systematic strategies employed to dehumanize Palestinians and facilitate land grabs. The memorialization of mass murderers of Palestinians, funded by the state, raises troubling questions about the sincerity of official condemnations of violence.
Coates then invokes Edward Said's powerful assertion that every empire justifies its actions by claiming exceptionalism. He connects this to Theodore Herzl's own civilizational hierarchy, which positioned Arabs as inferior. This historical context illuminates the ongoing disregard for international laws, such as the Geneva Conventions, designed to prevent such injustices. The Zionist dream, Coates argues, has often been predicated on the displacement of Palestinians, with archaeological claims used to retroactively justify these actions, often fueled by settler organizations with vested interests. The historical alliance between apartheid South Africa and Israel further underscores the systematic nature of oppression.
Coates' fearless writing shines through as he critiques the hypocrisy of the Museum of Tolerance being built on a destroyed Muslim graveyard, suggesting that the Holocaust narrative is sometimes weaponized to deflect from other injustices. His raw honesty resonates deeply, particularly for those who feel "gaslit" by dominant narratives surrounding ongoing conflicts.
Coates turns his attention to the selective outrage displayed by those in power, both political and celebrity. The fervent support for Ukraine stands in stark contrast to the silence or muted response regarding the plight of Palestinians, exposing a stark inconsistency in the application of Western values. The silence of many in Hollywood and the compromised stance of some musicians further underscore this unsettling reality.
Coates astutely points out that Jews are not a monolith and should not be held collectively responsible for the actions of the Israeli government. However, he argues that it is imperative for individuals, regardless of background, to speak out against genocide and ethnic cleansing, especially when such acts are committed in the name of their faith. The normalization of live-streamed war crimes, witnessed daily, is a chilling indictment of our desensitization to suffering. The failure to enact meaningful change after the 2008 financial crisis, the self-serving actions of politicians during the pandemic, and the protection of serial abusers all paint a picture of a status quo resistant to genuine accountability.
Coates also touches upon the power of grassroots movements, such as the BDS boycott, which authorities often fear and attempt to counter by fostering division. While wary of grand conspiracy theories, he acknowledges a concerted effort by those in power to embolden nationalism and silence dissenting voices, often ironically under the guise of defending free speech.
Ultimately, Coates echoes Moominmamma’s poignant reminder that "talking is all we have" and that our shared humanity outweighs our petty differences. Said warned about the self-serving narratives of empires and the complicity of intellectuals who rationalize injustice and The Message serves as a powerful antidote to such narratives, urging us to trust the evidence of our own eyes and to resist the comforting lies that perpetuate suffering. It is a vital read for anyone seeking a deeper, more honest understanding of the complexities and contradictions in our world.
LINK- The Anxious Generation: Book Review (and Some Thoughts)
LINK- Utopia for Realists- Book Review
LINK- ‘Natives: Race and Class in the Ruins of Empire’
LINK- Toxic: Women, Fame and the Noughties- Book Review (and Some Thoughts)